Fdtxjr

Good for you! in Russian

How do you like my writing?

My story is written in English, but is set in my home country. What language should I use for the dialogue?

Do items de-spawn in Diablo?

What Happens when Passenger Refuses to Fly Boeing 737 Max?

Grey hair or white hair

How do I deal with a powergamer in a game full of beginners in a school club?

Are the terms "stab" and "staccato" synonyms?

The bar has been raised

"One can do his homework in the library"

Best approach to update all entries in a list that is paginated?

Append a note to one of three files based on user choice

Are babies of evil humanoid species inherently evil?

Does splitting a potentially monolithic application into several smaller ones help prevent bugs?

Virginia employer terminated employee and wants signing bonus returned

How strictly should I take "Candidates must be local"?

Why does the negative sign arise in this thermodynamic relation?

Fourth person (in Slavey language)

Peter's Strange Word

Space in array system equations

Is there any way to damage Intellect Devourer(s) when already within a creature's skull?

Offered promotion but I'm leaving. Should I tell?

Is it true that real estate prices mainly go up?

Rejected in 4th interview round citing insufficient years of experience

Can two monic irreducible polynomials over $mathbbZ$, of coprime degrees, have the same splitting field?

Galois group of a degree 5 irreducible polynomial with two complex roots.Splitting field and dimension of irreducible polynomialsThe splitting fields of two irreducible polynomials over $Z / p Z$ both of degree 2 are isomorphicSplitting Field of Irreducible Polynomial over a Finite FieldSplitting field of cyclotomic polynomials over $mathbbF_2$.$5|#textGal(f/mathbbQ)subset S_5 implies textGal(f/mathbbQ)$ contains a $5$-cycle?Let $mathbbK$ the the splitting field of $x^4 -2 x^2 -2$ over $mathbbQ$. Determine all the subgroups of the Galois groupQuestion on splitting field and irreducible polynomials.Same Galois group for two polynomialsWhat quadratic field is contained in the splitting field of $x^5 - 4x - 2$ over $mathbbQ$?

5

$begingroup$

Let $f,g in mathbbZ[X]$ be monic polynomials. It is possible for distinct monic polynomials over $mathbbZ$ to have the same splitting field. For example $f = x^4 - 2$ and $g= x^4+2$ both have splitting field
$mathbbQ(sqrt[leftroot-2uproot24]2, i)$. Here $f,g$ are both irreducible with equal degrees.

Another example is $f=x^n - 1$ and $g=Phi_n(x)$, the $n$'th cyclotomic polynomial. The splitting field of both is the $n$'th cyclotomic field. In this case, $g$ is irreducible and divides $f$. The degree of $g$ is of course $varphi(n)$.

Question: Suppose $f,g$ are monic and irreducible, with coprime degrees. Say $deg f = n$ and $deg g = k$. Let us write $K_f$ and $K_g$ for their splitting fields.

Is it possible for these splitting fields to coincide, $K_f = K_g$? I am particularly interested in the case $k=n-1$.

I have attempted to approach the question using group theory. If we write $G$ for their common Galois group, then via the action of $G$ on the roots of $f$ and $g$ respectively, we would realize $G$ as a transitive subgroup of both $S_n$ and $S_k$. Therefore, as $k$ and $n$ are coprime

1. 
   $nk mid |G|$.


2. $|G| leq k!$


3. 
   $[S_n : G] geq n(n-1)cdots(k+1)$.

Furthermore, if $alpha$ is a root of $f$ and $beta$ is a root of $g$, then their stabilizers $Stab(alpha)$ and $Stab(beta)$ are subgroups of index $n$ and $k$ respectively. As these are coprime by assumption we would have $G = Stab(alpha)Stab(beta)$.

My conjecture is that this is not possible, but I am not able to show it. I seem to remember that, if $l < q$ then $S_l$ is never a transitive subgroup of $S_q$, except the case $S_5 leq S_6$. Here $S_5$ acts transitively on it's $5$-Sylow subgroups by conjugation, and there are $6$ of them. However, I might be wrong as I am unable to recover a reference for this. Of course, if this was true, we would simply strengthen 2. and 3. above to strict inequalities, unless $n=6$ and $k=5$.

I am also unaware whether there exists such a $f$ with degree $6$ and Galois group $S_5$ acting on the roots in this exotic manner.

group-theory polynomials galois-theory algebraic-number-theory irreducible-polynomials

share|cite|improve this question

edited 2 days ago

Sil

5,16421643

asked Mar 7 at 10:02

Emil LaursenEmil Laursen

263

$endgroup$

• 
  
  
  

  
  

  
  
  
  
  
  

  
  $begingroup$
  Another approach is to use the Chebotarev density theorem, see this MO-question.
  $endgroup$
  – Dietrich Burde
  Mar 7 at 10:24
  
  

  
  
  
  

add a comment | 

5

$begingroup$

Let $f,g in mathbbZ[X]$ be monic polynomials. It is possible for distinct monic polynomials over $mathbbZ$ to have the same splitting field. For example $f = x^4 - 2$ and $g= x^4+2$ both have splitting field
$mathbbQ(sqrt[leftroot-2uproot24]2, i)$. Here $f,g$ are both irreducible with equal degrees.

Another example is $f=x^n - 1$ and $g=Phi_n(x)$, the $n$'th cyclotomic polynomial. The splitting field of both is the $n$'th cyclotomic field. In this case, $g$ is irreducible and divides $f$. The degree of $g$ is of course $varphi(n)$.

Question: Suppose $f,g$ are monic and irreducible, with coprime degrees. Say $deg f = n$ and $deg g = k$. Let us write $K_f$ and $K_g$ for their splitting fields.

Is it possible for these splitting fields to coincide, $K_f = K_g$? I am particularly interested in the case $k=n-1$.

I have attempted to approach the question using group theory. If we write $G$ for their common Galois group, then via the action of $G$ on the roots of $f$ and $g$ respectively, we would realize $G$ as a transitive subgroup of both $S_n$ and $S_k$. Therefore, as $k$ and $n$ are coprime

1. 
   $nk mid |G|$.


2. $|G| leq k!$


3. 
   $[S_n : G] geq n(n-1)cdots(k+1)$.

Furthermore, if $alpha$ is a root of $f$ and $beta$ is a root of $g$, then their stabilizers $Stab(alpha)$ and $Stab(beta)$ are subgroups of index $n$ and $k$ respectively. As these are coprime by assumption we would have $G = Stab(alpha)Stab(beta)$.

My conjecture is that this is not possible, but I am not able to show it. I seem to remember that, if $l < q$ then $S_l$ is never a transitive subgroup of $S_q$, except the case $S_5 leq S_6$. Here $S_5$ acts transitively on it's $5$-Sylow subgroups by conjugation, and there are $6$ of them. However, I might be wrong as I am unable to recover a reference for this. Of course, if this was true, we would simply strengthen 2. and 3. above to strict inequalities, unless $n=6$ and $k=5$.

I am also unaware whether there exists such a $f$ with degree $6$ and Galois group $S_5$ acting on the roots in this exotic manner.

group-theory polynomials galois-theory algebraic-number-theory irreducible-polynomials

share|cite|improve this question

edited 2 days ago

Sil

5,16421643

asked Mar 7 at 10:02

Emil LaursenEmil Laursen

263

$endgroup$

• 
  
  
  

  
  

  
  
  
  
  
  

  
  $begingroup$
  Another approach is to use the Chebotarev density theorem, see this MO-question.
  $endgroup$
  – Dietrich Burde
  Mar 7 at 10:24
  
  

  
  
  
  

add a comment | 

$begingroup$

Let $f,g in mathbbZ[X]$ be monic polynomials. It is possible for distinct monic polynomials over $mathbbZ$ to have the same splitting field. For example $f = x^4 - 2$ and $g= x^4+2$ both have splitting field
$mathbbQ(sqrt[leftroot-2uproot24]2, i)$. Here $f,g$ are both irreducible with equal degrees.

Another example is $f=x^n - 1$ and $g=Phi_n(x)$, the $n$'th cyclotomic polynomial. The splitting field of both is the $n$'th cyclotomic field. In this case, $g$ is irreducible and divides $f$. The degree of $g$ is of course $varphi(n)$.

Question: Suppose $f,g$ are monic and irreducible, with coprime degrees. Say $deg f = n$ and $deg g = k$. Let us write $K_f$ and $K_g$ for their splitting fields.

Is it possible for these splitting fields to coincide, $K_f = K_g$? I am particularly interested in the case $k=n-1$.

I have attempted to approach the question using group theory. If we write $G$ for their common Galois group, then via the action of $G$ on the roots of $f$ and $g$ respectively, we would realize $G$ as a transitive subgroup of both $S_n$ and $S_k$. Therefore, as $k$ and $n$ are coprime

1. 
   $nk mid |G|$.


2. $|G| leq k!$


3. 
   $[S_n : G] geq n(n-1)cdots(k+1)$.

Furthermore, if $alpha$ is a root of $f$ and $beta$ is a root of $g$, then their stabilizers $Stab(alpha)$ and $Stab(beta)$ are subgroups of index $n$ and $k$ respectively. As these are coprime by assumption we would have $G = Stab(alpha)Stab(beta)$.

My conjecture is that this is not possible, but I am not able to show it. I seem to remember that, if $l < q$ then $S_l$ is never a transitive subgroup of $S_q$, except the case $S_5 leq S_6$. Here $S_5$ acts transitively on it's $5$-Sylow subgroups by conjugation, and there are $6$ of them. However, I might be wrong as I am unable to recover a reference for this. Of course, if this was true, we would simply strengthen 2. and 3. above to strict inequalities, unless $n=6$ and $k=5$.

I am also unaware whether there exists such a $f$ with degree $6$ and Galois group $S_5$ acting on the roots in this exotic manner.

group-theory polynomials galois-theory algebraic-number-theory irreducible-polynomials

share|cite|improve this question

edited 2 days ago

Sil

5,16421643

asked Mar 7 at 10:02

Emil LaursenEmil Laursen

263

$endgroup$

share|cite|improve this question

edited 2 days ago

Sil

5,16421643

asked Mar 7 at 10:02

Emil LaursenEmil Laursen

263

share|cite|improve this question

edited 2 days ago

Sil

5,16421643

asked Mar 7 at 10:02

Emil LaursenEmil Laursen

263

edited 2 days ago

Sil

5,16421643

edited 2 days ago

Sil

5,16421643

asked Mar 7 at 10:02

Emil LaursenEmil Laursen

263

asked Mar 7 at 10:02

Emil LaursenEmil Laursen

263