Conflicting names of ancestor's parents from different records?Locating an elusive UK birth record (Mary Ann Harper born circa 1865 possibly Dudley, England)?Where is the Marriage of Milly Bungay/Mason/Weston to John Weston?Where is the marriage of F. M. Weston/Mason to a Goodman?Where is the 1911 Census record relating to Milly Bungay/Mason/Weston?Finding an elusive ancestor after the 1901 census (who may have deserted his family)Can I determine the relationship between Mary Anne Wright (nee Harper) and Charles William Kimmons?Reading a Canadian 'Oceans Arrival' form completed in 1924What was surname of Susan/Susanna, wife of Edward McDowell, from Devon area in abt 1800?Seeking marriage record of John McGrady and Elizabeth McDonald in Ireland about 1885?How should I interpret this sequence of records?
What Exploit Are These User Agents Trying to Use?
Processor speed limited at 0.4 Ghz
Why was the shrink from 8″ made only to 5.25″ and not smaller (4″ or less)
How seriously should I take size and weight limits of hand luggage?
Avoiding the "not like other girls" trope?
Did 'Cinema Songs' exist during Hiranyakshipu's time?
What is the fastest integer factorization to break RSA?
Is it possible to create a QR code using text?
What is required to make GPS signals available indoors?
Is "/bin/[.exe" a legitimate file? [Cygwin, Windows 10]
Blending or harmonizing
Is there a hemisphere-neutral way of specifying a season?
Are British MPs missing the point, with these 'Indicative Votes'?
Does marriage to a non-Numenorean disqualify a candidate for the crown of Gondor?
Rotate ASCII Art by 45 Degrees
Is it possible to map the firing of neurons in the human brain so as to stimulate artificial memories in someone else?
Why do I get negative height?
My ex-girlfriend uses my Apple ID to log in to her iPad. Do I have to give her my Apple ID password to reset it?
GFCI outlets - can they be repaired? Are they really needed at the end of a circuit?
Unlock My Phone! February 2018
Why was Sir Cadogan fired?
In Bayesian inference, why are some terms dropped from the posterior predictive?
How can I prove that a state of equilibrium is unstable?
What does the same-ish mean?
Conflicting names of ancestor's parents from different records?
Locating an elusive UK birth record (Mary Ann Harper born circa 1865 possibly Dudley, England)?Where is the Marriage of Milly Bungay/Mason/Weston to John Weston?Where is the marriage of F. M. Weston/Mason to a Goodman?Where is the 1911 Census record relating to Milly Bungay/Mason/Weston?Finding an elusive ancestor after the 1901 census (who may have deserted his family)Can I determine the relationship between Mary Anne Wright (nee Harper) and Charles William Kimmons?Reading a Canadian 'Oceans Arrival' form completed in 1924What was surname of Susan/Susanna, wife of Edward McDowell, from Devon area in abt 1800?Seeking marriage record of John McGrady and Elizabeth McDonald in Ireland about 1885?How should I interpret this sequence of records?
Winnifred Lydia O'Brien
1896–1979
BIRTH 30 OCT 1896 • Stroud, Gloucestershire, England
DEATH 28 NOV 1979 • New Westminster, British Columbia, Canada
I believe I have found my great-grandmother in the 1926 census of the prairie provinces.
https://www.bac-lac.gc.ca/eng/census/1926/Pages/item.aspx?itemid=890822
Line 6 in the image.
She was also found in the death index:
Winifred Lydia Fowler, "British Columbia Death Registrations, 1872-1986; 1992-1993"
https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:FL1S-HQZ
As well as in the 1901 England census:
https://www.ancestry.ca/sharing/16091326?h=e6067d&o_xid=61785&o_lid=61785&o_sch=Email+Programs
https://www.ancestry.ca/sharing/16091335?h=4da97d&o_xid=61785&o_lid=61785&o_sch=Email+Programs
However, the names of her parents keeps changing in the records.
On her death cert it says Edward O’Brien of Ireland was her father with an unknown mother.
On the 1901 census it says her mother is Norah O’Brien and the head of the household is Edward Goode but it doesn’t say what relation he has to her.
I found a marriage cert that has a marriage between Norah O’Brien and George Edward Goode.
I guess it could be that she didn't take her husband's last name. 
england marriage-records surnames vital-records canada
edited Mar 20 at 22:09
PolyGeo♦
7,02152049
asked Mar 20 at 14:53
user1261710user1261710
1765
add a comment |
Winnifred Lydia O'Brien
1896–1979
BIRTH 30 OCT 1896 • Stroud, Gloucestershire, England
DEATH 28 NOV 1979 • New Westminster, British Columbia, Canada
I believe I have found my great-grandmother in the 1926 census of the prairie provinces.
https://www.bac-lac.gc.ca/eng/census/1926/Pages/item.aspx?itemid=890822
Line 6 in the image.
She was also found in the death index:
Winifred Lydia Fowler, "British Columbia Death Registrations, 1872-1986; 1992-1993"
https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:FL1S-HQZ
As well as in the 1901 England census:
https://www.ancestry.ca/sharing/16091326?h=e6067d&o_xid=61785&o_lid=61785&o_sch=Email+Programs
https://www.ancestry.ca/sharing/16091335?h=4da97d&o_xid=61785&o_lid=61785&o_sch=Email+Programs
However, the names of her parents keeps changing in the records.
On her death cert it says Edward O’Brien of Ireland was her father with an unknown mother.
On the 1901 census it says her mother is Norah O’Brien and the head of the household is Edward Goode but it doesn’t say what relation he has to her.
I found a marriage cert that has a marriage between Norah O’Brien and George Edward Goode.
I guess it could be that she didn't take her husband's last name.
england marriage-records surnames vital-records canada
edited Mar 20 at 22:09
PolyGeo♦
7,02152049
asked Mar 20 at 14:53
user1261710user1261710
1765
3
The marriage is after the census, so not likely to see name changes before then for anyone. Names on death certificates are always suspicious because the most informed person isn't there. Surnames of children born before their parents marriage are always problematic in England - sometimes they changed, sometimes not.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 15:18
Am I right in saying that the only real oddity is the death certificate, which isn't that odd....?
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 15:20
add a comment |
Winnifred Lydia O'Brien
1896–1979
BIRTH 30 OCT 1896 • Stroud, Gloucestershire, England
DEATH 28 NOV 1979 • New Westminster, British Columbia, Canada
I believe I have found my great-grandmother in the 1926 census of the prairie provinces.
https://www.bac-lac.gc.ca/eng/census/1926/Pages/item.aspx?itemid=890822
Line 6 in the image.
She was also found in the death index:
Winifred Lydia Fowler, "British Columbia Death Registrations, 1872-1986; 1992-1993"
https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:FL1S-HQZ
As well as in the 1901 England census:
https://www.ancestry.ca/sharing/16091326?h=e6067d&o_xid=61785&o_lid=61785&o_sch=Email+Programs
https://www.ancestry.ca/sharing/16091335?h=4da97d&o_xid=61785&o_lid=61785&o_sch=Email+Programs
However, the names of her parents keeps changing in the records.
On her death cert it says Edward O’Brien of Ireland was her father with an unknown mother.
On the 1901 census it says her mother is Norah O’Brien and the head of the household is Edward Goode but it doesn’t say what relation he has to her.
I found a marriage cert that has a marriage between Norah O’Brien and George Edward Goode.
I guess it could be that she didn't take her husband's last name.
england marriage-records surnames vital-records canada
edited Mar 20 at 22:09
PolyGeo♦
7,02152049
asked Mar 20 at 14:53
user1261710user1261710
1765
Winnifred Lydia O'Brien
1896–1979
BIRTH 30 OCT 1896 • Stroud, Gloucestershire, England
DEATH 28 NOV 1979 • New Westminster, British Columbia, Canada
I believe I have found my great-grandmother in the 1926 census of the prairie provinces.
https://www.bac-lac.gc.ca/eng/census/1926/Pages/item.aspx?itemid=890822
Line 6 in the image.
She was also found in the death index:
Winifred Lydia Fowler, "British Columbia Death Registrations, 1872-1986; 1992-1993"
https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:FL1S-HQZ
As well as in the 1901 England census:
https://www.ancestry.ca/sharing/16091326?h=e6067d&o_xid=61785&o_lid=61785&o_sch=Email+Programs
https://www.ancestry.ca/sharing/16091335?h=4da97d&o_xid=61785&o_lid=61785&o_sch=Email+Programs
However, the names of her parents keeps changing in the records.
On her death cert it says Edward O’Brien of Ireland was her father with an unknown mother.
On the 1901 census it says her mother is Norah O’Brien and the head of the household is Edward Goode but it doesn’t say what relation he has to her.
I found a marriage cert that has a marriage between Norah O’Brien and George Edward Goode.
I guess it could be that she didn't take her husband's last name.
england marriage-records surnames vital-records canada
england marriage-records surnames vital-records canada
edited Mar 20 at 22:09
PolyGeo♦
7,02152049
asked Mar 20 at 14:53
user1261710user1261710
1765
edited Mar 20 at 22:09
PolyGeo♦
7,02152049
asked Mar 20 at 14:53
user1261710user1261710
1765
edited Mar 20 at 22:09
PolyGeo♦
7,02152049
edited Mar 20 at 22:09
PolyGeo♦
7,02152049
edited Mar 20 at 22:09
PolyGeo♦
7,02152049
7,02152049
asked Mar 20 at 14:53
user1261710user1261710
1765
asked Mar 20 at 14:53
user1261710user1261710
1765
asked Mar 20 at 14:53
user1261710user1261710
1765
1765
3
The marriage is after the census, so not likely to see name changes before then for anyone. Names on death certificates are always suspicious because the most informed person isn't there. Surnames of children born before their parents marriage are always problematic in England - sometimes they changed, sometimes not.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 15:18
Am I right in saying that the only real oddity is the death certificate, which isn't that odd....?
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 15:20
add a comment |
3
The marriage is after the census, so not likely to see name changes before then for anyone. Names on death certificates are always suspicious because the most informed person isn't there. Surnames of children born before their parents marriage are always problematic in England - sometimes they changed, sometimes not.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 15:18
Am I right in saying that the only real oddity is the death certificate, which isn't that odd....?
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 15:20
3
3
The marriage is after the census, so not likely to see name changes before then for anyone. Names on death certificates are always suspicious because the most informed person isn't there. Surnames of children born before their parents marriage are always problematic in England - sometimes they changed, sometimes not.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 15:18
The marriage is after the census, so not likely to see name changes before then for anyone. Names on death certificates are always suspicious because the most informed person isn't there. Surnames of children born before their parents marriage are always problematic in England - sometimes they changed, sometimes not.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 15:18
Am I right in saying that the only real oddity is the death certificate, which isn't that odd....?
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 15:20
Am I right in saying that the only real oddity is the death certificate, which isn't that odd....?
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 15:20
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
I suggest you obtain a copy of Winifred's birth certificate. It can be ordered from the GRO website.
In the New GRO index, here is her entry:
As you can see, the Mother's maiden surname is given as a dash, indicating she was very likely illegitimate.
The most likely explanation is that Winifred's mother was unmarried when Winifred was born. Whether Edward Goode was her biological father is impossible to say without further evidence.
As you say, Norah appears to have married George Edward Goode in December 1901 (remember the census was taken in March 1901, before they were married).
The 1911 census does not help much although it shows Winifred O'Brien with her mother Norah Goode and several O'Brien and Goode siblings. Her stepfather is not there at that time. (see reference RG 14/15370, schedule 99)
DNA testing can be useful to sort out paternity in some cases where there is a recent illegitimacy.
answered Mar 20 at 15:22
Harry Vervet♦Harry Vervet
14.3k42683
Good point that EG might not be her biological father. It's not unknown for so-called fathers' names to be step-fathers'. Certainly in the UK there are a lot less rules about these things than you might imagine and even fewer requirements for proof! Who people trace in their tree is, of course, up to them.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 17:56
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "467"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fgenealogy.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f15308%2fconflicting-names-of-ancestors-parents-from-different-records%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
I suggest you obtain a copy of Winifred's birth certificate. It can be ordered from the GRO website.
In the New GRO index, here is her entry:
As you can see, the Mother's maiden surname is given as a dash, indicating she was very likely illegitimate.
The most likely explanation is that Winifred's mother was unmarried when Winifred was born. Whether Edward Goode was her biological father is impossible to say without further evidence.
As you say, Norah appears to have married George Edward Goode in December 1901 (remember the census was taken in March 1901, before they were married).
The 1911 census does not help much although it shows Winifred O'Brien with her mother Norah Goode and several O'Brien and Goode siblings. Her stepfather is not there at that time. (see reference RG 14/15370, schedule 99)
DNA testing can be useful to sort out paternity in some cases where there is a recent illegitimacy.
answered Mar 20 at 15:22
Harry Vervet♦Harry Vervet
14.3k42683
Good point that EG might not be her biological father. It's not unknown for so-called fathers' names to be step-fathers'. Certainly in the UK there are a lot less rules about these things than you might imagine and even fewer requirements for proof! Who people trace in their tree is, of course, up to them.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 17:56
add a comment |
I suggest you obtain a copy of Winifred's birth certificate. It can be ordered from the GRO website.
In the New GRO index, here is her entry:
As you can see, the Mother's maiden surname is given as a dash, indicating she was very likely illegitimate.
The most likely explanation is that Winifred's mother was unmarried when Winifred was born. Whether Edward Goode was her biological father is impossible to say without further evidence.
As you say, Norah appears to have married George Edward Goode in December 1901 (remember the census was taken in March 1901, before they were married).
The 1911 census does not help much although it shows Winifred O'Brien with her mother Norah Goode and several O'Brien and Goode siblings. Her stepfather is not there at that time. (see reference RG 14/15370, schedule 99)
DNA testing can be useful to sort out paternity in some cases where there is a recent illegitimacy.
answered Mar 20 at 15:22
Harry Vervet♦Harry Vervet
14.3k42683
Good point that EG might not be her biological father. It's not unknown for so-called fathers' names to be step-fathers'. Certainly in the UK there are a lot less rules about these things than you might imagine and even fewer requirements for proof! Who people trace in their tree is, of course, up to them.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 17:56
add a comment |
I suggest you obtain a copy of Winifred's birth certificate. It can be ordered from the GRO website.
In the New GRO index, here is her entry:
As you can see, the Mother's maiden surname is given as a dash, indicating she was very likely illegitimate.
The most likely explanation is that Winifred's mother was unmarried when Winifred was born. Whether Edward Goode was her biological father is impossible to say without further evidence.
As you say, Norah appears to have married George Edward Goode in December 1901 (remember the census was taken in March 1901, before they were married).
The 1911 census does not help much although it shows Winifred O'Brien with her mother Norah Goode and several O'Brien and Goode siblings. Her stepfather is not there at that time. (see reference RG 14/15370, schedule 99)
DNA testing can be useful to sort out paternity in some cases where there is a recent illegitimacy.
answered Mar 20 at 15:22
Harry Vervet♦Harry Vervet
14.3k42683
I suggest you obtain a copy of Winifred's birth certificate. It can be ordered from the GRO website.
In the New GRO index, here is her entry:
As you can see, the Mother's maiden surname is given as a dash, indicating she was very likely illegitimate.
The most likely explanation is that Winifred's mother was unmarried when Winifred was born. Whether Edward Goode was her biological father is impossible to say without further evidence.
As you say, Norah appears to have married George Edward Goode in December 1901 (remember the census was taken in March 1901, before they were married).
The 1911 census does not help much although it shows Winifred O'Brien with her mother Norah Goode and several O'Brien and Goode siblings. Her stepfather is not there at that time. (see reference RG 14/15370, schedule 99)
DNA testing can be useful to sort out paternity in some cases where there is a recent illegitimacy.
answered Mar 20 at 15:22
Harry Vervet♦Harry Vervet
14.3k42683
answered Mar 20 at 15:22
Harry Vervet♦Harry Vervet
14.3k42683
answered Mar 20 at 15:22
Harry Vervet♦Harry Vervet
14.3k42683
answered Mar 20 at 15:22
Harry Vervet♦Harry Vervet
14.3k42683
14.3k42683
Good point that EG might not be her biological father. It's not unknown for so-called fathers' names to be step-fathers'. Certainly in the UK there are a lot less rules about these things than you might imagine and even fewer requirements for proof! Who people trace in their tree is, of course, up to them.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 17:56
add a comment |
Good point that EG might not be her biological father. It's not unknown for so-called fathers' names to be step-fathers'. Certainly in the UK there are a lot less rules about these things than you might imagine and even fewer requirements for proof! Who people trace in their tree is, of course, up to them.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 17:56
Good point that EG might not be her biological father. It's not unknown for so-called fathers' names to be step-fathers'. Certainly in the UK there are a lot less rules about these things than you might imagine and even fewer requirements for proof! Who people trace in their tree is, of course, up to them.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 17:56
Good point that EG might not be her biological father. It's not unknown for so-called fathers' names to be step-fathers'. Certainly in the UK there are a lot less rules about these things than you might imagine and even fewer requirements for proof! Who people trace in their tree is, of course, up to them.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 17:56
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Genealogy & Family History Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fgenealogy.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f15308%2fconflicting-names-of-ancestors-parents-from-different-records%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
3
The marriage is after the census, so not likely to see name changes before then for anyone. Names on death certificates are always suspicious because the most informed person isn't there. Surnames of children born before their parents marriage are always problematic in England - sometimes they changed, sometimes not.
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 15:18
Am I right in saying that the only real oddity is the death certificate, which isn't that odd....?
– AdrianB38
Mar 20 at 15:20